Monday, September 20, 2010

The Papal visit to Britain...

A story from slightly further afield this week month:

I was inspired to finally update this blog after reading this fantastic post by Stephen Fry on his website, available at http://www.stephenfry.com/2010/09/16/dailymailhate/single-page/.

For the benefit of his international readers, and his British ones who have some taste in newspapers, he explains that a recent edition of the Daily Mail has denounced him as the leader of an atheist hate campaign against the Pope’s state visit to Britain.

I can’t explain the brilliance of his riposte without quoting the whole thing verbatim but the facts are: 
  • Stephen Fry is merely a signatory to a petition against the Pope’s visit, not the leader of ‘hate campaign’. 
  • This petition features numerous public intellectuals in Britain such as Geoffrey Robertson, Richard Dawkins, Christopher Hitchens and Philip Pullman. 
  • Oddly enough, the article doesn’t mention that David Attenborough, one of the most trusted men in Britain, is also a signatory. 
  • Fry asks, could it be something to do with the fact that the Daily Mail is giving away a free DVD of Attenborough’s documentaries along with that very issue of the paper?
Both Dawkins and Hitchens have stated that they did not create this campaign - that the credit belongs to Geoffrey Robertson (‘a candidate for greatest-living Australian’ – Hitchens) – although this hasn’t prevented their opponents from apportioning most of the blame to the world’s most notorious atheists.

Much of the drive against the visit has come from the furore throughout this year over the child-abuse revelations, but the official campaign against the visit has not been taking this approach. The official line is that the Pope does not represent a state, and for that reason the cost of the visit should not be foisted upon the British taxpayer, especially since the government is planning to apply an austerity programme to the British economy.

I was pleased to see that the great majority of left-wing commentators made it clear that they weren’t attacking the great majority of Catholics, merely those implicated in the child-abuse scandal. An example is a columnist for the Independent, Johann Hari, who attempts to appeal to all of the ordinary Catholics who were horrified by the revelations of paedophilia (http://www.independent.co.uk/opinion/commentators/johann-hari/johann-hari-catholics-its-you-this-pope-has-abused-2074029.html). Having read articles and blog posts in which commentators such as Hari have made their stance clear, it was slightly amusing to read some of the more off-the-planet pro-Pope writings.

My favourite was this particularly baffling one from the aforementioned Daily Mail (http://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-1310358/Those-oppose-Pope-Benedict-XVIs-visit-real-bigots.html?ito=feeds-newsxml#ixzz0z8dDu4Wu), which argues that Dawkins is a hypocrite to protest the state visit of the Pope because there is no record of him taking a similar stand against the state visit of Romanian dictator Nicolae Ceausescu back in 1978.

Seriously.

If arguments against this are needed, here are a few: 
  • No one in 1978 was disputing that Ceausescu represented a state.
  • This was during the era of détente, and to rebuff him could have had significant implications for the relationship between the USSR and the West. Remember, everyone thought the Cold war would go on indefinitely and no one wanted to rock the boat.
  • Ceausescu, for all his crimes, wasn’t presiding over a paedophile ring that extended into the United Kingdom.

My heart goes out to Fry, Robertson, Dawkins, Hitchens, Hari and everyone else on this mission. I’ve been there myself. 

UPDATE: Another example of a left-wing writer appealing to conflicted Catholics is Jeremy Sear at An Onymous Lefty. http://anonymouslefty.wordpress.com/2010/09/19/protests-against-pope-not-against-his-subjects/

UPDATE #2: Now the Pope has gone home there's a interesting analysis of the protest by Laurie Penny on her blog Penny Red: http://pennyred.blogspot.com/2010/09/lessons-from-pope-protest.html