Wednesday, November 24, 2010

The results are in!

36/40

"Hi Jonathan,

Your Political Scrutineer blog is very witty. I really like the antagonistic, but well-informed, stance you’ve taken in your criticism. The writing is clever and erudite; each post has a clearly defined angle and they are all very structured. Whether you are writing about Julian Assange, Howard v’s Costello or the LHC (and the loonies who have decided it will kill us all), you make your topics interesting. Your posts also illustrate a depth of research that brings weight to your particular perspective on an issue.

Don’t stop just because you’ve passed this course!"
- Dr. Morgan Richards (BA Hons UNSW, PhD Cambridge)

Aw, shucks...

Monday, November 8, 2010

My blog synopsis and farewell

Well, it's been fun. This is the last you'll hear of me, unless I fail and have to do it all again next year. Goodbye

Here's the synopsis of my blog which I've finally submitted via TurnItIn:


My blog has quite a broad focus, with the stipulated subject being ‘politics’. This can mean anything from current events to the political dimensions of a book or film that I encountered recently. I would do my best to meet the expectations of my readers, but the main criterion would be to write about matters that interest me, because if I’m not engaged by my writing then I don’t believe anyone else will be. While a more relaxed, website of left-wing commentary would be a satisfactory home for my blog, attempting to write sober, in-depth political analysis would be a mistake for me. There are far too many aspiring journalists who are more politically aware than I am; I feel that the only thing I’ve got going for me as a writer is a lightness of tone.

I believe that there is a sizeable audience who are intelligent and well-read, yet feel intimidated by the culture of 24-hour rolling news and non-stop political spin. British columnist and TV presenter Charlie Brooker had this audience in mind when he made his BBC4 show NewsWipe. He targeted it at people, like himself, who had an interest in current events or felt an obligation to pay attention to them, yet could never keep up with the news. This is the sort of audience I am seeking – down to Earth and possessing a sense of humour, while being made to feel inadequate and uninformed by more serious political analysis.
I recognised my writing technique in a recent column by Brooker, who told his readers: “To everyone who has ever emailed to ask me for advice on writing, my answer is: get a deadline. That's all you really need. Forget about luck. Don't fret about talent. Just pay someone larger than you to kick your knees until they fold the wrong way if you don't hand in 800 words by five o'clock.” I have been following that philosophy since I was a child at primary school. Being employed by a professional media organisation; knowing that I depended on the income from my blog for my living, and being aware I was at the mercy of an editor who could dispense judgement if I failed to deliver regularly, would work wonders for my output.

I have to admit that I don’t often think in terms of ‘audiences’ or ‘markets’, and I didn’t let them trouble me for a moment when I was originally setting up the blog. One of my models would be the Jack Marx Affair, a blog at news.com.au. It’s author, the Walkley award winning Jack Marx, is a notoriously undisciplined writer. He posts on the blog quite sporadically, and only on subjects that interest him. The main attraction for the audience is his humour and his style of writing. Of course, I can’t write with anything like the panache that he can, but his blog is proof that quality can win out over pure marketability.

This might be quite an unpopular view among those who exist to sell newspapers and publicise websites, but I am convinced that it more important to create something of quality than finding a market to sell it in before it has been developed. My attitude is that if a writer’s work is of quality, then it will find an audience.

Obscurantism is held at bay...

Today, the human race is our subject, and how, despite everything, it can pleasantly surprise you.

The last 24 hours have seen a momentary defeat of obscurantism and fearfulness by the forces of science and rationality. The Large Hadron Collider has been successfully used to create a miniature big bang, according to much of the news media (http://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/back-to-the-beginning-hadron-collider-creates-minibig-bang-2128785.html), it is a triumph for the scientists who have been working on this project for years. Best of all however, there were no reports about ill-informed simpletons who feared this would bring about the end of the universe.

I hope you can remember that back in 2008, the media treated this subject with glee, for they could make predictions of doom unheard of since the millennium bug. It was reported that there was widespread fear that the collider would bring about the creation of a black hole, or perhaps another universe which will forcibly take the place of this one. Indeed, I can think of few headlines more amusing than “Woman, fearing apocalypse, tries to halt collider” (http://news.cnet.com/8301-17852_3-10467056-71.html). It was getting so ridiculous, even Jeremy Clarkson bemoaned, “we celebrate our ignorance of the Large Hadron Collider” (http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/comment/columnists/jeremy_clarkson/article4880908.ece).

A large website was developed entitled LHCdefense.org – the official site for citizens against the Large Hadron Collider, with their slogan being “Stop the LHC – until we know it’s SAFE!” Sing as the whole point of the experiment is to break new ground, how can they know if it’s safe unless they test it? I’m pretty sure that the scientists operating the machine are satisfied with it’s safety; I can’t imaging they’d enjoy being sucked into a black hole.

It pleased me to note that this was an American organisation whose advice for concerned citizen was either to give them money, or to ‘write your congressman’ (sic). Clearly, the fact that the experiment was taking place in Switzerland and beyond the authority of the U.S. government was lost on them.

I don’t pretend that I understand the science behind it even for a moment, but I do realise that ignorance is a good reason to keep one’s opinions to oneself (apart from this blog, of course).

Julian Assange...

It’s standard practice for Julian Assange to claim that journalists aren’t reporting the real stories, especially on matters in which he is involved. However, his current circumstances do raise an issue that I feel ought to be better examined.

Last month, Assange was denied residency in Sweden, with the justification being the mysterious rape charge (http://www.icenews.is/index.php/2010/10/27/assange-denied-residency-in-sweden/).  Now, if the evidence ultimately shows that he is guilty on this change then I will happily see to see him get what he deserves. You should ask yourself, however, why would a man on the verge of striking a blow for truth and press freedom suddenly commit a heinous crime of this nature and give everyone a weapon to use against him?

In a recent interview on Al Jazeera television (http://english.aljazeera.net/programmes/listeningpost/2010/11/201011673237731559.html), Assange brought up the possibility of having to apply for asylum in countries such as Cuba or Russia, if he is unable to find safety in the West. At the present he is seeking asylum in Switzerland (http://news.smh.com.au/breaking-news-technology/wikileaks-founder-may-seek-swiss-asylum-interview-20101105-17gbx.html), but if that bid is similarly unsuccessful his options look very thin.
Assange is one of the most polarizing figures around, able to inspire or disillusion people on a number of subjects. In my case, I had hopes for the alternative media until I listened to an interview with him about how he originally envisioned Wikileaks would operate. (I won’t quote it here – partly because I feel I’ve been doing too much quoting and not enough writing, but mainly because I can’t find the damn transcript. )

One of the points he made was that stories are almost never broken via the alternative media (blogs and so forth). The excuse often made for this is than bloggers, not being properly funded journalists, don’t have the resources to make contacts and break stories. Hence they can only comment on stories already broken by the traditional media. As Assange put it, this is “all bullshit!”.

WikiLeaks, when first established, catered to that audience and attempted to provide them with never-before-seen documents with which they could break stories. They found that almost no one was interested, that bloggers only write to show off their political opinions to their friends, rather than actually attempt to effect change. Without a paycheck, most so-called journalists aren’t interested in reading tedious papers in the hope of finding a story.

If us bloggers aren’t going to be doing proper journalistic investigations then the least we can do is have some intelligent discussions. To start with, what does it say about the liberal western world that Julian Assange may be forced to seek asylum from it? 

Sunday, November 7, 2010

Nationwide madness...

There were quite a few reasons to watch the news on Tuesday, the 2nd of November 2010. In the United States of American the Democratic party was preparing for a disastrous result in the mid-term elections, while praying for one that was merely bad (http://www.abc.net.au/rn/breakfast/stories/2010/3054474.htm). In Iran, a 43-year-old mother of two was about to be stoned to death for the crime of adultery, human rights advocates announced (http://www.iranfocus.com/en/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=22131:french-supporters-fear-iranian-woman-to-be-stoned-wednesday-&catid=6:women&Itemid=28). And closer to home, broadcaster Derryn Hinch risked several years in prison by publically naming and shaming two sex offenders, in violation of a court order (http://www.news.com.au/breaking-news/hinch-not-sorry-for-naming-sex-offenders/story-e6frfku0-1225946539753). However, on that day, all of those matters were pushed aside, because a horse won the Melbourne cup.

Jeremy Sear of An Onymous Lefty reported an unusual case of déjà-vu (http://anonymouslefty.wordpress.com/2010/11/02/horse-wins-the-melbourne-cup/); today, people were fascinated by the way in which a horse managed to run around a track slightly faster than several other horses. More importantly, the nation of Australia, seemingly in a fit of madness, decided to pay attention to this phenomenon and treat it as if it were of genuine value and  importance.

According to Sear, the astonishing story goes thus: “It was 3pm on 2nd November 2010, and there were about twenty horses lined up at the start of a racetrack in Flemington, Melbourne. They ran around the track. One horse won by taking less time to do this than the other horses. One horse came second, one came third and so on. And there was much rejoicing/weeping, depending on which horse the various people had backed. And this went on for a few days until everyone remembered that for the rest of the year they don’t give a shit about horse racing.”

At the ABC Unleashed blog, there is another concerned commentator, Marieke Hardy, who is dreadfully worried about the effects on ‘Spring Carnival Fever’ on her home city of Melbourne (http://www.abc.net.au/unleashed/40668.html). There are some truly horrific symptoms, such as “dressing like a complete twat with scant regard to the weather forecast, blowing wads of cash on an archaic industry that actively supports the whipping of under-developed animals, and eventually teetering home covered in a fine spray of puke and semen." It does appear that the affliction wears off, as Sear point out, after a matter of days, but Hardy is taking no chances: “If pain persists, shoot yourself”.

I concur.

Howard vs. Costello (as per usual)

There was a very fine piece in the Sydney Morning Herald the other day by Peter Hartcher about the rivalry between John Howard and Peter Costello - the dispute in Australian politics that will not die, even after those have left the business. (http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/politics/dont-mention-the-economy-20101029-177go.html)

In short, Howard’s book resurrects most of his old criticisms of Costello and the party, arguing that they should have effected a better leadership transition. Hartcher points out that this was certainly going to make a splash once the memoir was published, as it was the only real news story in the book.

I’m focusing on one writer in this post because of Hartcher’s rare position between the two major parties. Three and a half years ago he wrote an issue of the Quarterly Essay that performed an impressive balancing act regarding who should be credited for Australia’s economic success. (Remember, this was before the Global Financial Crisis). The essay pointed out that Labor’s greatest failing after the fall of Keating was to discard his legacy of financial reform, allowing Howard and the rest of his government to take all of the credit for the next decade of economic sunshine. Howard has acknowledged the wisdom of the Hawke-Keating economic reforms (http://anonymouslefty.wordpress.com/2010/10/29/john-labor-did-more-than-vote-for-conservative-policies-they-enacted-them-in-government/), which was more than Labor did at the time.

Anyway, Hatcher makes the point that Howard was a fool for attacking Costello. This is because Costello is far more valuable to the Liberal party and far more respected now than he was as Treasurer. For the Liberal party, he is proof of past economic successes; they use him as a stamp of approval. He gets wheeled out whenever the Coalition announce an economic policy and need its quality to be certified.  

Costello returned fire in the Fairfax press after the Howard’s memoir was published, saying what pretty much everyone else thought: that the Liberal party’s loss in 2007 was the fault of Howard for staying too long as Prime Minister, refusing to leave even after those around him asked him to. (http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/politics/failure-in-2007-was-all-howards-doing-20101026-172aw.html)

Many of Howard’s supporters such as Janet Albrechtsen, and former members of his government have expressed their disappointment with the way he has lowered himself into the political game once again. Instead of appearing as a clean and upright statesman, which is the image most politicians choose to adopt after a lifetime of climbing the greasy pole, he is instead trying to settle old scores.

Hartcher points out that Howard, by raising the issue in this fashion and refusing to accept the responsibility for the coalition’s flaws, has damaged his legacy such that it will always be tainted. If Howard tries to take credit for the economic successes of his government, he will always be contested by Costello, who has learned that the former Prime Minister will not let things go and will never accept the blame for their election defeat.  

It’s funny isn’t it?