Sunday, November 7, 2010

Howard vs. Costello (as per usual)

There was a very fine piece in the Sydney Morning Herald the other day by Peter Hartcher about the rivalry between John Howard and Peter Costello - the dispute in Australian politics that will not die, even after those have left the business. (http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/politics/dont-mention-the-economy-20101029-177go.html)

In short, Howard’s book resurrects most of his old criticisms of Costello and the party, arguing that they should have effected a better leadership transition. Hartcher points out that this was certainly going to make a splash once the memoir was published, as it was the only real news story in the book.

I’m focusing on one writer in this post because of Hartcher’s rare position between the two major parties. Three and a half years ago he wrote an issue of the Quarterly Essay that performed an impressive balancing act regarding who should be credited for Australia’s economic success. (Remember, this was before the Global Financial Crisis). The essay pointed out that Labor’s greatest failing after the fall of Keating was to discard his legacy of financial reform, allowing Howard and the rest of his government to take all of the credit for the next decade of economic sunshine. Howard has acknowledged the wisdom of the Hawke-Keating economic reforms (http://anonymouslefty.wordpress.com/2010/10/29/john-labor-did-more-than-vote-for-conservative-policies-they-enacted-them-in-government/), which was more than Labor did at the time.

Anyway, Hatcher makes the point that Howard was a fool for attacking Costello. This is because Costello is far more valuable to the Liberal party and far more respected now than he was as Treasurer. For the Liberal party, he is proof of past economic successes; they use him as a stamp of approval. He gets wheeled out whenever the Coalition announce an economic policy and need its quality to be certified.  

Costello returned fire in the Fairfax press after the Howard’s memoir was published, saying what pretty much everyone else thought: that the Liberal party’s loss in 2007 was the fault of Howard for staying too long as Prime Minister, refusing to leave even after those around him asked him to. (http://www.smh.com.au/opinion/politics/failure-in-2007-was-all-howards-doing-20101026-172aw.html)

Many of Howard’s supporters such as Janet Albrechtsen, and former members of his government have expressed their disappointment with the way he has lowered himself into the political game once again. Instead of appearing as a clean and upright statesman, which is the image most politicians choose to adopt after a lifetime of climbing the greasy pole, he is instead trying to settle old scores.

Hartcher points out that Howard, by raising the issue in this fashion and refusing to accept the responsibility for the coalition’s flaws, has damaged his legacy such that it will always be tainted. If Howard tries to take credit for the economic successes of his government, he will always be contested by Costello, who has learned that the former Prime Minister will not let things go and will never accept the blame for their election defeat.  

It’s funny isn’t it? 

No comments:

Post a Comment