Thursday, October 28, 2010

On abortion (I'd like to say goodbye to half my audience)

On the subject of the abortion trial that recently took place in Cairns, there was a truly excellent post on the subject by journalist and author John Birmingham on his blog at the Brisbane Times. (http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/opinion/blogs/blunt-instrument/where-do-you-stand-on-abortion-anna/20101014-16kz2.html)

Directing his writing at the Anna Bligh, the Queensland premier, Birmingham said, “If you do not believe in a woman's right to abortion, that's fine. Lots of people don't, because of genuine, deeply-held beliefs. But if you do not believe that Tegan Leach has the right to control her own fertility, you should have the courage to come out and say so rather than hiding behind the flimsy rhetorical defense of ‘letting the law take its course’. That law is there because you refuse to change it. You need to get up now and tell the women of Queensland where you and your government stand.” As he said, the supposed leaders in Queensland did not do what was required of them, and it was only by the actions of a dozen independently thinking men and women that the lives of this young couple have not been further stifled.

His point was both timely and yet timeless. He argued that the law is certainly not a guide to what is right or wrong, and for the premier and the rest of an elected government to simply avoid taking responsibility in a matter such as this, was a gross dereliction of their duty. This is not to say that a better society would be one with mob rule or driven primarily by feelings rather than thought, but that one must consider the ethical legitimacy of the laws that they are compelled to obey.

The prosecutor told the court “you are not sitting in a court of morals” and that if they disagreed with the law they should “make their views known at the ballot box”. But if neither of the major parties is going to represent the views held be a large proportion of the electorate, what else can be done to bring about change?

No comments:

Post a Comment