Thursday, October 28, 2010

On abortion (I'd like to say goodbye to half my audience)

On the subject of the abortion trial that recently took place in Cairns, there was a truly excellent post on the subject by journalist and author John Birmingham on his blog at the Brisbane Times. (http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/opinion/blogs/blunt-instrument/where-do-you-stand-on-abortion-anna/20101014-16kz2.html)

Directing his writing at the Anna Bligh, the Queensland premier, Birmingham said, “If you do not believe in a woman's right to abortion, that's fine. Lots of people don't, because of genuine, deeply-held beliefs. But if you do not believe that Tegan Leach has the right to control her own fertility, you should have the courage to come out and say so rather than hiding behind the flimsy rhetorical defense of ‘letting the law take its course’. That law is there because you refuse to change it. You need to get up now and tell the women of Queensland where you and your government stand.” As he said, the supposed leaders in Queensland did not do what was required of them, and it was only by the actions of a dozen independently thinking men and women that the lives of this young couple have not been further stifled.

His point was both timely and yet timeless. He argued that the law is certainly not a guide to what is right or wrong, and for the premier and the rest of an elected government to simply avoid taking responsibility in a matter such as this, was a gross dereliction of their duty. This is not to say that a better society would be one with mob rule or driven primarily by feelings rather than thought, but that one must consider the ethical legitimacy of the laws that they are compelled to obey.

The prosecutor told the court “you are not sitting in a court of morals” and that if they disagreed with the law they should “make their views known at the ballot box”. But if neither of the major parties is going to represent the views held be a large proportion of the electorate, what else can be done to bring about change?

Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Does satire have any effect?

John Lloyd is one of the unknown heroes of British comedy, having produced programmes such as the Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy for radio, and Blackadder, Not the Nine O’clock News, and recently QI for TV. He was also one of the pivotal figures in the making of Spitting Image, on of the most successful topical shows in Britain during the mid 1980s, thanks to it’s cast of grotesque rubber caricatures of all of the public figures of the day. The most abused figures on the show were those of Margaret Thatcher and her government, since the show was unashamedly left-wing.

Thanks to Spitting Image, I know more about Thatcher’s cabinet from the 1980s than I do about Julia Gillard’s cabinet in 2010. This was the effect that it had on much of Britain at the time, to the point that even children could name various government ministers.

Today I’ve read two interviews with Lloyd that touch on his history with the programme, and in both of them he raises the question of whether it had any effect on the political situation at all. The first was a wide-ranging discussion originally printed in the Idler magazine and later made available on their website (http://idler.co.uk/conversations/conversations-john-lloyd/), and the second was published on the website of Vice magazine, as part of a general retrospective of the show (http://www.viceland.com/int/v17n10/htdocs/booze-drugs-violence-and-madness-567.php?page=1).

In the first interview, published on the website of the Idler magazine, he explains: “I tried for years as a satirical television producer to better the world. I just made it worse, actually”. In his view, the vicious attitude of the programme towards the Thatcher’s government acted as a release valve for everyone on the left. This, he argues, was reflected in the letters sent in by viewers:

Says Lloyd, ‘We used to get hundreds of letters every week which could roughly be divided into two piles. There were the “You cunts! You Bastards! You Should all be shot!” category, and there were the others that said, “I was going to kill myself last week because I’ve been unemployed for 4 years, my wife’s left me and I’m such a useless person, but I thought I’d just watch Spitting Image before I go, and I had such a good laugh about Thatcher being beaten over the head with a truncheon that I thought I’d give it another week.”’

The interviewer summed it up: “so Spitting Image acted as a kind of anaesthetic, numbing people from going out and rioting”.

Does satire achieve anything? Are there any examples of it changing society significantly for the better?

I’m now worried that the answer to both of those questions is ‘no’.

Any consoling thoughts?

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

My presentation...

The slides for my in-class presentation are finally available on SlideShare: http://www.slideshare.net/JonathanHead/mdia5003-presentation

I was quite pleased with the way it went. The following week a fellow student told me that my speech had caused her to despair at the prospect of finding decent journalistic work.

At least they were listening.

Monday, October 25, 2010

Let's all point and laugh...

(Sorry. I wrote this and one other entry earlier, but I’ve been prevented from posting them due to Internet difficulties.)

Finally, a splash of humour! I hope you’ve heard of the Liberal MP Don Randall who made a spectacular fool of himself on TV by contemptuously dismissing what he thought were Greens policies, only to find that they were actually the work of his party’s Shadow Treasurer, Joe Hockey.

Aside from lamenting the general standard of government in western society – ‘no one ever thinks about whether a policy is good or bad, they only care about which party supports it’ – today’s objective is to point and laugh. I’m glad to see that the Sydney Morning Herald feels the same way (http://www.smh.com.au/national/the-day-don-made-a-twitter-of-himself-20101021-16uz8.html?autostart=1).

Randall has a history of making questionable statements. Back in September the Coalition was doing everything they could to rubbish the minority government that had only just formed in Canberra. Randall’s objection to it stood out from the crowd. He explained his plan for changing the country’s government: “We’re only one death, one desertion and one sickness away from the ability to change the (composition) of this house”.

He added, sinisterly, “we’ll be doing our best to keep this government to account and if that opportunity arises it’ll be fantastic.” (http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2010/09/30/3026131.htm)
Oh, and in July he also said that Julia Gillard’s atheism would be the undoing of her at the then upcoming election. He said of his electorate, “they don’t like the fact that we have got a godless Prime Minister”. 

Even Tony Abbott thought that this attitude needed to be squashed: “I just want to make it clear that attacks on people based on their religion have no place in this election campaign and will not be made by me”. (http://news.yahoo.com.au/thewest/a/-/mp/7648954/lib-says-gillards-godlessness-a-vote-loser/)

I have to ask, was I the only person who nodded understandingly when they learned that the boneheaded MP was from Western Australia? Or is this just an example of typical elitism and snobbery on my part?

It’s probably the latter. But still…