Friday, August 20, 2010

The Republic Debate

In the final week of the election campaign, the debate of whether Australia should become a republic was reignited briefly when Julia Gillard commented that her intention was for Australia to reconsider the issue after the death of the current Queen, Elizabeth II. In her words, "I think that the appropriate time for this nation to move to being a republic is when we see the monarch change". Abbott responded with his own view, that the monarchical system worked perfectly well and there were no grounds for replacing it: "I see no reason whatsoever why they can't continue to work well into the future". (http://www.abc.net.au/news/stories/2010/08/17/2985152.htm)

The reaction to this topic was quite disappointing in the Australian press, with little being done apart from reproducing the views of the two competing leaders. (Almost all the other articles I could find merely repeated the same quotes). Very little coverage was given to the position of the Greens party and their leader Bob Brown. The only mention I could find was in article on the Greens education policies in the Australian (http://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/brown-wants-2bn-rise-in-mining-tax-to-fund-public-schools/story-fn59nlz9-1225906880060). The positions of Gillard and Abbott, and the coverage given to them are disappointing, given that polling has consistently shown that a majority of Australians want this country to become a republic. The real debate is over what form it should take.

The reaction to the debate in the United Kingdom has been slightly more interesting. The ‘debate’ received a tiny mention during the Guardian’s coverage of the knife-edge conclusion to the campaign. The views of the two candidates were detailed, but no judgements made about them. (http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2010/aug/20/australia-election)

A google news search revealed an article in the Daily Mail suggesting that Britons should adopt Gillard’s stance when it comes to the monarchy; that the whole system should be reformed after the passing of Elizabeth II.

While initially surprising to see pro-republican arguments in such a backward-looking newspaper, it soon becomes obvious that this is merely a method for the newspaper to express its regular contempt towards the environmentalist Charles Windsor.

(On a side note, which will only be of interest to few, the article was by Jan Moir, notorious winner of the Stonewall Bigot of the Year Award for 2009.)

(I hasten to add that I do not, under normal circumstances, read the Daily Mail. I definitely do not in any way endorse the views it expresses. Indeed, I would not dare handle a printed copy without donning rubber gloves. It is mentioned in this post only because Google served it up to me.)

The rest of the reaction in the UK press to the issue is best summed up in a quote from the beloved Scottish comedian Billy Connolly. While on tour in Australian in 1995, he encouraged the then upcoming referendum on the issue, while reminding his audience: “but don’t think you’re going to shock the British, who already think you are a f**king republic.”

I have to admit that I’m not sure what I should be saying in this post. Is it acceptable to lambaste the press reportage on this issue for not reflecting my views satisfactorily? Just in case it is, here are my grievances with the coverage.  To wait for the death of Elizabeth Windsor before we have another proper debate on the issue of a republic means the issue could well be sidelined for the next two decades. Her mother lived until the age of 101, and by delegating more and more duties to her son, it is quite possible that she will live to a comparable age.

Waiting until her death before reigniting the debate is just a delaying tactic on the part of those who don’t want the status quo disrupted. If we do as they ask and wait, then we will have to deal with claims that Charles has been doing the monarch’s job for years without fault, and it would be a personal insult to dismiss him as soon as he formally accedes to the position.

If the monarchical system genuinely is broken and inappropriate, then it needs replacement regardless of whether the monarch is competent or popular. Elizabeth Windsor may have become an institution herself, but that does not mean she should remain the ruler of a country that is growing ever more distant from its colonial roots.

No comments:

Post a Comment